Skip to content
DesignMind AI

This is an example review. Start your own.

Quick Walk-through

A finished example review of Fernway Learn, an online platform with AI skills courses and an AI tutor, for Working professionals moving into AI roles.

Model:
google/gemini-3.8-flash

Product tour

A short, silent walkthrough: adding screenshots on the home page, then exploring this review's pins and tabs.

Steps

7 of 7 steps finished

  1. 1Image searchFinds screens from real, well-rated apps that look like your design45sDone
  2. 2Visual analysisLayout, spacing, colour, type and hierarchy17sDone
  3. 3UX critiqueNielsen’s 10 usability heuristics20sDone
  4. 4AccessibilityMeasures contrast and sizes against WCAG 2.222sDone
  5. 5Market researchSearches the web for competitors and trends60sDone
  6. 6Design comparisonPicks the stronger design in each area5sDone
  7. 7Lead reviewerRemoves repeats, ranks the fixes and scores each design18sDone

The 5 indented agents work at the same time.

Marked-up design

Pins show the top 10 ranked fixes. Hover over or tap a pin to see the fix.

Landing page5 fixes pinned
Landing page with 5 pinned fixes

Hover over or tap a pin to see the fix.

  1. 1P0 Increase text contrast on hero primary CTA button 'Get Started' to at least 4.5:1
  2. 3P0 Darken hero body copy to achieve at least 4.5:1 contrast against the pastel gradient background
  3. 5P1 Replace blank skeleton lines in 'Your learning path' card with realistic curriculum milestones and AI tutor artifacts
  4. 6P1 Darken 'Trusted by teams' proof copy to satisfy minimum 4.5:1 text contrast
  5. 10P2 Replace top-right navigation icon controls with high-contrast, labeled actions such as 'Log in'
Mobile sign-up5 fixes pinned
Mobile sign-up with 5 pinned fixes

Hover over or tap a pin to see the fix.

  1. 2P0 Add persistent visible text labels above form inputs and increase placeholder/text contrast
  2. 4P1 Change the registration modal primary CTA label from 'Submit' to 'Create account'
  3. 7P1 Increase target size and contrast for modal 'Close dialog' button
  4. 8P1 Darken Terms of Service checkbox label and login footer link on registration modal
  5. 9P1 Replace ambiguous command loop icon with recognized OAuth provider branding and accessible labels

Executive summary

Fernway Learn presents a contemporary, clean aesthetic tailored to career-driven AI upskilling, featuring a structured landing hero and a focused registration modal. However, severe accessibility failures compromise both screens: primary CTA buttons, input placeholders, and body copy fail WCAG contrast minimums, with ratios as low as 1.48:1 and 1.80:1. Usability is further hampered by vanishing input labels, a generic 'Submit' button label, and empty skeleton wireframe cards that fail to showcase the platform's core AI tutor value proposition. Addressing these contrast deficits and replacing generic placeholders with authentic interactive course previews will significantly improve conversion and trust.

Landing page

72
Visual design76
Usability74
Accessibility58
Market fit80

Mobile sign-up

72
Visual design78
Usability75
Accessibility54
Market fit82

Ranked fixes

  1. 1

    Increase text contrast on hero primary CTA button 'Get Started' to at least 4.5:1

    The white text on light indigo background measures 1.95:1 (#f5feff on #a5b4fd), failing WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.3 and rendering the primary landing page conversion button illegible for many users.

    P0Impact highEffort SOwner devScreen AFound by Accessibility

    Sources:wcag-contrast-text

  2. 2

    Add persistent visible text labels above form inputs and increase placeholder/text contrast

    Inputs for 'Full name', 'Email', and 'Password' lack persistent labels and measure only 1.80:1–1.81:1 (#c1c0c4 on #ffffff). Disappearing labels cause cognitive load during entry, violating WCAG 1.3.1 and 1.4.3.

    P0Impact highEffort SOwner designScreen BFound by UX critique, Visual analysis, AccessibilityDraws on Codecademy

    Sources:wcag-labelsformsscreen-B#1wcag-contrast-text

  3. 3

    Darken hero body copy to achieve at least 4.5:1 contrast against the pastel gradient background

    The subhead copy measures 2.41:1 (#9b9ead on #f3f2fd), failing WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.3 and creating severe readability issues for prospective learners evaluating the value proposition.

    P0Impact highEffort SOwner devScreen AFound by Accessibility

    Sources:wcag-contrast-text

  4. 4

    Change the registration modal primary CTA label from 'Submit' to 'Create account'

    'Submit' is non-descriptive and generic; using action-oriented language clearly indicates the outcome of account creation and aligns with modern onboarding standards.

    P1Impact medEffort SOwner designScreen BFound by Visual analysis, UX critiqueDraws on DataCamp

    Sources:craft-writing-labelsforms

  5. 5

    Replace blank skeleton lines in 'Your learning path' card with realistic curriculum milestones and AI tutor artifacts

    The preview card displays abstract skeleton placeholder bars with empty whitespace below, failing to demonstrate tangible course outcomes, adaptive tutoring features, or career tracks.

    P1Impact highEffort MOwner designScreen AFound by Visual analysis, UX critiqueDraws on Coursera

    Sources:craft-herocraft-subjectempty-states

  6. 6

    Darken 'Trusted by teams' proof copy to satisfy minimum 4.5:1 text contrast

    Text measures 1.48:1 (#d0d4d8 on #fdfefe), making social proof almost invisible to prospective users and failing WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.3.

    P1Impact medEffort SOwner devScreen AFound by Visual analysis, Accessibility

    Sources:craft-quality-floorwcag-contrast-text

  7. 7

    Increase target size and contrast for modal 'Close dialog' button

    The close button has an estimated target size of only 12×15 CSS px (failing SC 2.5.8) and measures 2.68:1 (#9b9ea0 on #fefefe, failing SC 1.4.11), posing tap and visibility barriers.

    P1Impact medEffort SOwner devScreen BFound by Accessibility

    Sources:wcag-non-text-contrastwcag-target-size

  8. 8

    Darken Terms of Service checkbox label and login footer link on registration modal

    The legal label measures 2.64:1 (#a09ea2 on #fefefe) and login text measures 2.70:1 (#9b9ca2 on #fdfefe), both failing WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.3 and causing legal/navigation illegibility.

    P1Impact medEffort SOwner devScreen BFound by Accessibility

    Sources:wcag-contrast-textwcag-target-size

  9. 9

    Replace ambiguous command loop icon with recognized OAuth provider branding and accessible labels

    The third SSO button displays an abstract loop (⌘) rather than a recognizable provider (like GitHub or Apple), and buttons lack explicit accessible names for screen reader users.

    P1Impact medEffort SOwner designScreen BFound by UX critique, AccessibilityDraws on Codecademy

    Sources:wcag-labelsscreen-B#2

  10. 10

    Replace top-right navigation icon controls with high-contrast, labeled actions such as 'Log in'

    The header icons measure 2.07:1 non-text contrast (#b3b3b9 on #fefefe) and fail SC 2.5.8 target size (76×16 px), while lacking visible labels or clear sign-in affordances.

    P2Impact lowEffort SOwner designScreen AFound by UX critique, AccessibilityDraws on DataCamp

    Sources:wcag-non-text-contrastwcag-target-sizewcag-labelsscreen-A#1

  11. 11

    Adjust text contrast and tap targets on header 'Courses' and 'Learn more' links

    'Courses' measures 4.20:1 (#797b7f on #fdfefe) and 'Learn more' measures 4.08:1 (#716ebc on #f3f3fe), falling just short of the 4.5:1 requirement.

    P2Impact lowEffort SOwner devScreen AFound by Accessibility

    Sources:wcag-contrast-textwcag-target-size

  12. 12

    Standardize hero headline typography to a uniform high-contrast color

    Splitting the headline with periwinkle colored spans ('AI skills') follows a generic SaaS template trope that dilutes typographical hierarchy compared to weight-based emphasis.

    P2Impact lowEffort SOwner designScreen AFound by Visual analysis

    Sources:craft-typography

Quick wins

  • Update primary button copy on Screen B from 'Submit' to 'Create account'.
  • Darken 'Get Started' button background or text color on Screen A to meet 4.5:1 contrast.
  • Add persistent text labels above Full Name, Email, and Password form fields on Screen B.
  • Darken secondary microcopy ('Trusted by teams...', 'Start learning in minutes.', and Terms label) to satisfy WCAG AA.
  • Expand clickable padding on modal close button and header navigation icons to 44×44 px minimum.
Start a new review